September 12, 2009 Mr Walker, It’s All Over: Gender Politics in Office Songs
Nowaytomakealiving.net is named after a mishearing of the Dolly Parton song 9 to 5, one of a small number of songs about office work. 9 to 5 is the theme song to the 1980 film, where Dolly Parton, Lily Tomlin and Jane Fonda seek revenge on a sexist boss who harasses them and steals their ideas. Gender politics, the constraint of living within industrialised organisational time, solidarity in the workplace and the unfulfilments of work (‘There’s a better life, and you think about it don’t you?’) are all themes in the film, which the song hints at (here sung with the surprising assistance of adults dressed as disney characters).
The narrator in Billie Jo Spears’ 1969 country song Mr Walker it’s all Over could have done with some female colleagues like Dolly, Lily and Jane. ‘I don’t like the New York Secretary’s life’, and who can blame her, when it’s too full of men, from the company president on down, with hands ‘reaching out to grab the things that I consider mine’. So she’s heading back to Garden City, Kansas, because ‘the boy next door don’t know it but come June he’s gonna gain himself a wife’. A late-1960s experiment with women working in the big city is here doomed to failure, and an earlier femininity is reasserted.
Step into the Office Baby by Belle and Sebastian is also about office politics and sexual harassment. Here, the roles are reversed, as we might expect in a post-feminist world. She says
We need to talk Step into my office, baby I want to give you the job A chance of overtime Say my place at nine
He, though, isn’t sure. He’s ‘a slave to work’, he’s ‘only living when I walk amongst office staff’. And he’s not sure that he wants the sort of overtime she has in mind.
She wants him to sharpen up, be a man, complete with retro phallic necktie.
I've got to change my ways Dress for business every day A sharp suit and a kipper tie A big arrow pointing to my fly
It’s not just the inversion of heteronormative expectations that’s notable in the contrast between Mr Walker and Step into the Office, it’s the meaning of private sphere. In 1969, she could escape back home, where her mom and her man will save her. In 2003, he has nowhere to hide: his own place isn’t a sanctuary from work, but a place where work is in his head ‘in bed by nine, my thoughts composed’, and he succumbs to the office affair, goes to her place to ‘take down her little red dress’. The office is no escape from sexual politics.